Q re "Unknown author" and date of composition

You are here

In The Lutheran Hymnal [HymnalID: LH1941], the editors describe the authorship of several hymns as "Author unknown, xxxx" where xxxx is the year the hymn was written. That is, they know the date it was written but not the author, and explicitly say so.

In trying to preserve this data in the INSTANCE record, however, we run into a problem. In the INSTANCE record, it appears that one cannot leave the Name and Authority fields blank (the direction given in the wiki for an unknown author) while at the same time entering a Relationship (in this case, author) and a Date. Thus, leaving the author field blank eliminates the ability to keep the given date of composition for these hymns.

Would it be helpful to create a generic "Author Unknown" person, with a description that says something like "In some hymnals, the editors noted that a hymn's author is unknown to them, and so this artificial "person" entry is used to reflect that fact. Obviously, the hymns attributed to "Author Unknown" were written by many people over a span of many centuries. On the other hand, if a hymnal simply did not list an author for a particular hymn, nothing will be entered in the Author field."

Just a thought.

Peter Rehwaldt


Comments

Peter,

You are right that there is no way to add a date of composition without adding an author. Perhaps we should raise this issue on the editorial committee list.

---------------
Harry Plantinga
CCEL Director

I would enter it the way the hymnal states - "Author unknown" in the Author field. The authority is "Anonymous". Some hymnals use "Anonymous" or "Anon." for authors, translators, or other relationships also. So there is a generic "person" named "Anonymous". I hadn't thought about adding a description, but that's a good idea.

It looks like you are using an ad-blocker. Ad revenue helps keep us running. Please consider white-listing Hymnary.org or subscribing to eliminate ads entirely and help support Hymnary.org.