Hymnary.org will be unavailable January 30th, 6:00 to 9:00 PM EST for system maintenance. Thank you for your patience. Hide this message

Choosing is over now

You are here

Haruo's picture

Yesterday, I indexed the second instance of Douglas Wilson's "Blest now (or is) the man who does not walk" (the one in TPHr2022). I noticed the difference between the first line of Wilson's text as indexed in the 2002 Cantus Christi (Blest now...) and the 2022 Treasury of Psalms and Hymns (revised), so I wrote to Mr. Wilson and asked him which he would prefer be merged into the other at the text authority level. He replied,

"Leland, thanks for checking. There were a few slight changes between the 2002 Cantus and the 2020 Cantus, and the Treasury I believe, reflects those changes."

This suggests to me that it would best be indexed under "is", but when I went in to do so, I found that someone had already merged them into "now". Even though the 2020 Cantus Christi is still not in the database, I think it would be best to move the current "now" text authority to "is". But I'm not sure if this runs counter to some little codicil in the editors' instructions packet. What is the standard in a case like this? Dianne?



You are welcome to change the authority and authority id to the preferred version. I chose to merge the new version into the existing version. In general, it is best to use the authority id that editors will find and the authority text that users will be familiar with.

It looks like you are using an ad-blocker. Ad revenue helps keep us running. Please consider white-listing Hymnary.org or subscribing to eliminate ads entirely and help support Hymnary.org.